Jonathan Agnew VANCE

                   11/15/09 - I officially lose her in the family after 1880.

* There was a Minnie Vance born about a year earlier, father was William Vance. They lived in Pomeroy, Meigs, OH.
                  

                   1880 - She was 8 at the time of the census.
1900 - living with parents in Columbus. She  was single with no children. She was a buggy top sticker.

There is a Maud Vance who died in Franklin County on 25 Nov 1918.

The birth record is for a female, born 6 Mar 1872. Could there have been twins??This one is not named.
                  

                   Probably was the one who died before 1900.
                  

                   Birth Records of Knox, OH, have him as Charley Vance.
Not sure about the Charles E. Vance who married a Dell Stinemetz  on 14 Apr 1898, in Knox County. Can't find them anywhere else.

1900 - living with parents in Columbus, OH. He was a machinist. He was single. Iofficially lose him after that.

This one matches.....almost. Birthdate is about a year off.
I doubt it 11/15/09 - in the 1930 census - his parents were both born in PA. OurCharles's parents were both born in OH.
1920 United States Federal Census  about Charles E Vance
Name:	Charles E Vance
Home in 1920:	Forest Home, Antrim, Michigan
Age:	43 years
Estimated Birth Year:	abt 1877
Birthplace:	Ohio
Relation to Head-of-house:	Head
Spouse's name:	Reatha
Father's Birth Place:	Ohio
Mother's Birth Place:	Ohio
Marital Status:	Married
Race:	White
Sex:	Male
Home owned:	Own
Able to read:	Yes
Able to Write:	Yes
Image:	724
Neighbors:
Household Members:	Name	Age
	Charles E Vance 	43
	Reatha Vance 	30
	Walter L Vance 	11/12
                  

                   1900 - he was living with his parents in Columbus, OH. He was single, he was a switchman.
1920 - he was living in Columbus with his dad. He was single. He was an intake tender  at the RR.

1900 census has his birthdate as Jun 1879. Draft registration has May 10, 1879. I took the draft registration.

World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918 about Joseph Moore Vance
Name:	Joseph Moore Vance
City:	Columbus
County:	Franklin
State:	Ohio
Birth Date:	10 May 1879
Race:	White
Roll:	1832030
DraftBoard:	3

Sep 12, 1918 - Draft registration . He was living at 591 Hamlet, Columbus Ohio. He was an intake tender at the Union .... His relative was John A. Vance, same address. He had brown hair and brown eyes.